Signs It's Time To Replace Your Toilet in Mentor, Ohio

Formica Plumbing and Sewer Co.
12 June 2025
Water Heater Replacement in Solon, OH

Would you know when to replace toilets in your home? While some signs are obvious, subtle ones often go undetected by homeowners.



At Formica Plumbing and Sewer Co., we're passionate about quality plumbing repair services in Mentor, OH, from Mentor Marsh Nature Preserve to Lakeland Community College. You can stay comfortable in your home if you can avoid the plumbing disasters we’ve mentioned below.


Call for Service in Mentor When You Notice These Common Toilet Problems

When you understand the most common toilet problems, you can call for service before they cause widespread damage throughout your home.


Frequent Clogging Requires Professional Attention

While you can expect a toilet to clog occasionally, more frequent clogs indicate widespread problems. First, determine if other drains, like your shower or sinks, also clog repeatedly. If so, you likely have a problem with your sewer line or some other shared pipe in your home.


When the toilet is the only fixture with a problem, you may save money by upgrading it. Even with the best plumbing techniques, the issue may return continually. Instead of spending money on multiple service calls, why not invest in a new unit?


Constant Leaks May Indicate a Problem Beyond Repair

If you're wondering when to replace toilets, ask yourself how often they leak. A leaky toilet can manifest in several ways, including:

  • Running constantly, even when you don't flush it
  • Pooling water around the base
  • Dripping outside the tank or bowl
  • Loosening or corroding fasteners
  • Emerging water damage around the wall near the supply pipe

Much like frequent clogs, these leaks can result in significant costs over time. If they come back even after repairs, opt for a toilet replacement instead.


Don't Settle for Damage That Seems Superficial

Many homeowners settle for a toilet with cracked porcelain if they don't see water leaking from it. However, toilet damage is rarely only aesthetic. You don’t want to leave the fixture vulnerable to more serious problems, such as when a toilet starts wobbling and damages the floor or wall around it.


A certified plumber in Mentor can determine the extent of the damage. Experts like Formica Plumbing and Sewer Co. may suggest upgrading the toilet if it is a cost-effective solution.


Toilet Problems Can Result in Rising Water Bills 

When toilet problems go undetected, they can cause your water bills to increase significantly because of inefficient flushing or leaks that drip constantly. If you can't explain your rising utility bill with a rate hike or increased usage, you'll need a Mentor plumber’s meticulous inspection skills.


The problem may not lie with your toilet, but the expert won't fail to check the fixture. When you install a modern model, you'll appreciate the increased comfort, style, and efficiency.


Upgrade Your Toilet When It Grows Too Old

Many toilets can last up to 50 years, especially with maintenance. They rarely operate efficiently beyond the first couple of decades, though. If you're wondering when to replace toilets, the general guidelines suggest every 25 years.


Don't hesitate to update an outdated toilet model for stylistic or comfort reasons, too. If you've updated your shower or vanity, your old fixture may clash and ruin the effect. Your plumber can help find a cost-effective replacement that meets all your needs.


A Plumber’s Best Tips for Toilet Care

How can you care for your toilet so that it lasts longer and stays efficient? One best practice is scheduling annual plumbing maintenance. The appointment includes checking your toilet and taking preventative measures against damage.

You should also clean your toilet regularly. While many plumbers suggest daily cleanings, even weekly attention helps. Use the following method:

  1. Remove any rugs or other obstacles near the toilet. 
  2. Put on gloves and a cloth mask to stay safe and healthy.
  3. Spray the inside of the bowl with a dedicated cleaner. 
  4. Wait about 15 minutes before scrubbing it with a toilet brush.
  5. Flush the toilet and clean the bowl again if needed.
  6. Clean the base, seat, bowl, and other surfaces with a disinfecting spray and paper towel.

Then, check the floor and toilet for any remaining stains and apply any finishing touches.

Prevent Water Heater Blowups & Breakdowns in Solon, OH

Schedule Prompt Toilet Repairs in Mentor Today

Now that you know when to replace toilets in Mentor, you can call Formica Plumbing and Sewer Co. to address all the causes of toilet base leaks and help your entire system run more efficiently. Whether you live near Reynolds or Mentor Headlands, you get the same excellent quality of service and competitive prices. Schedule an appointment by contacting us today!

when to replace kitchen faucet
by SEOCH 11 September 2025
Learn when to replace your kitchen faucet with Formica Plumbing and Sewer Co. in Chesterland, OH. Protect cabinets, cut costs, and avoid repairs.
why does my bathroom sink drain gurgle
by SEOCH 11 September 2025
Wondering why your bathroom sink drain gurgles? Formica Plumbing and Sewer Co. explains the causes and provides expert plumbing services in Chardon, OH.
how to repair a leaking kitchen faucet
by SEOCH 11 September 2025
Learn how to repair a leaking kitchen faucet with tips from Formica Plumbing and Sewer Co. Contact us for expert faucet repair in Timberlake, OH.
water heater smells like rotten eggs
by SEOCH 11 September 2025
Wondering what’s causing your water heater to smell like rotten eggs? Contact Formica Plumbing and Sewer Co. for plumbing repair in University Heights, OH.
signs of bad pressure relief valve water heater
by Josh Crouch 15 August 2025
What are the signs of a bad pressure relief valve in a water heater? We’ll cover debris in water, excessive valve noise, and other warnings in Chagrin, OH.
how to fix black water coming out of faucet
by SEOCH 15 August 2025
Do you want to know how to fix black water coming out of the faucet? In this blog post, we list the most common culprits and how to properly address them.
why is my shower head whistling
by SEOCH 15 August 2025
Why is my shower head whistling? Read our blog post where we go over the possible causes, from heavy mineral buildup to faulty valves and high water pressure.
why is my toilet water brown
by SEOCH 15 August 2025
Why is my toilet water brown? Read on as we help you narrow down the possible causes, from the presence of iron bacteria to rusty pipes and fixtures.
25 July 2025
Learn how to detect water leaks in your house early with expert tips from Formica Plumbing and Sewer Co., your trusted plumber in Concord, Ohio.
25 July 2025
Learn how to use a plumbing snake with this step-by-step guide from Formica Plumbing and Sewer Co., trusted by homeowners in Shaker Heights, Ohio.